Curation as a New Translation: Diane Arbus at Fraenkel Gallery, Huffington Post

DIANE ARBUS Two ladies at the automat, N.Y.C. 1966 © The Estate of Diane Arbus

DIANE ARBUS Two ladies at the automat, N.Y.C. 1966 © The Estate of Diane Arbus

I am not cruel, only truthful—
The eye of a little god, four-cornered.
Mirror,
 Sylvia Plath

Diane Arbus famously brought a dispassionate but probing voyeurism to the marginalized and pariah of our society. Her treatments of the denizens of the mainstream are no less discomfiting. In “Diane Arbus 1971-1956,” Fraenkel Gallery has assembled 60 photographs of the late artist and grouped them according to themes strained from Arbus’s notebooks and letters. Images appear in reverse chronological order in groups under “The Mysteries that Bring People Together,” “Interiors: The Meanings of Rooms,” “People Being Somebody,” “Recognition,” and “Winners and Losers,” headings chosen and curated by Jeffrey Fraenkel.

The categories are hardly beyond questioning. In the coyly-titled Two friends at home, N.Y.C. 1965, what is apparently a lesbian couple stand in their bedroom. One, in a skirt, pointy glasses, and a feminine updo, rests her arm around her lover’s shoulders. The other, in pants and a man’s shirt and slicked-back, cropped hair, looks at the camera, with her hands in her pockets. The image would make sense under “The Mysteries that bring people together.” It could reasonably fall under “People Being Somebody” — after all, one could deduce from the women’s costume and toilette that they self-identify as “femme” and “butch.” Depending on one’s views on love and its pitfalls, and the fact that one woman looks hard into her lover’s face, while her lover in turn looks away — it could even reasonably be included as a witty addition to “Winners and Losers.” But Fraenkel has placed the image with “Interiors: the meanings of rooms.” This compels one to examine the room the lovers are placed in with a mind to divining its significance, and possibly to give it more interpretive weight than if one were simply considering all elements of the picture equally. And so the eye falls on the crumpled bed, admittedly bestowed importance if not primacy by the photographer by its large and central place in the composition, and the fact that aside from the windows, it is the brightest thing in the frame. It is also the scene of their perceived crime, for even in a progressive city like New York, in the years preceding Stonewall there were still laws limiting the rights of LGBT people, as well as widespread casual harassment and prejudice. The “meaning” of their room is different from that of other couples’ rooms: it is not only the seat of intimacy but a hideout from the nosy hostility of a benighted era.

 DIANE ARBUS Couple arguing, Coney Island, N.Y. 1960 © The Estate of Diane Arbus

DIANE ARBUS
Couple arguing, Coney Island, N.Y. 1960
© The Estate of Diane Arbus

Thus Fraenkel’s categorization draws historical and social context into the picture, steering us to consider it through an interpretive lens determined not by Arbus or by our own proclivities, but by Fraenkel himself. One can resent the imposition or be grateful for it — indeed, there are worse people than Jeffrey Fraenkel to be guiding one’s examination of photographs. His exhibit from earlier this year, “The Unphotographable,” demanded (and rewarded) a rigorous intellectual engagement with the pieces, the unphotographability of which was in many cases due to the fact that the subject was an idea rather than a visible object — the moment of death, a dream, the passage of time, the enormity of an event like 9/11. But while in that show, it was understood that many of the artists had been grappling with that subject — how to photograph something that isn’t “so readily seen” — the themes of this show were not chosen by the artist but by the gallerist showing her work, themes that he gleaned from her notebooks and correspondence and that he determined to have special importance, and then grouped the images according to his own interpretations of them. It is a muscular, even manipulative, curatorial conceit, and one that invites skepticism. However persuasive are Fraenkel’s extrapolations, they necessarily say more about Fraenkel himself than they do about Diane Arbus. However one might wish to achieve some hermetic communion with her work, one ends up examining it under the considerable influence of his subjective take on it.

Of course that hermetic communion is impossible anyway; Arbus’s fame is too great and many of the images in the current exhibit are renowned in the canon. Even the less well-known ones lend themselves to being viewed as examples of the scholarly sang froid that won Arbus her place in the pantheon. Such photographs as A blind couple in their bedroom, Queens, N.Y. 1971, which depicts a couple relaxing in each other’s arms on their bed, a representation of tenderness so much like any other except for that thing that is not quite right about their eyes, or Santas at the Santa Claus School, Albion, N.Y. 1964, men of mid- to late-middle age who in their youth one might assume had different career goals from this — “Diane Arbus: 1971-1956″ is full of depictions of both marginalized people and the marginalia of the quotidian, depictions that are neither judgmental nor particularly compassionate, revelations of the kind of lives we might dread to lead, without the assuasive evidence of redemption. The people she referred to in her letters as “retarded,” “freaks,” “morons,” “mongoloids,” “idiots,” and “imbeciles” (which, even in that era of unreconstructed attitudes and language, one suspects were not the kindest words to use about her varied subjects) appear without sentimentality, without the sort of visual euphemisms an artist might use to soften a difficult and fearsome subject. Take Five Children in a common room, N.J. 1969: mentally and/or physically impaired kids play or just sit in probably the world’s grimmest common room (bare walls and a toddler’s tricycle, it seems, were deemed enough to create a jolly atmosphere for these children, one of whom appears to be a teenager). They live with conditions each of us counts ourselves lucky not to be burdened with, and fear to pass on in our own progeny; they scare and shame us — “What if that were me?” “Why is he smiling like that?” “Why do I complain about anything in my life, ever??” Yet Arbus doesn’t labor to show their humanity, or offer any sort of palliative to our traumatized sensibilities. Even her photographs of people who aren’t necessarily “freaks” showcase her unmerciful truthtelling.

DIANE ARBUS Veteran with a flag, N.Y.C. 1971 © The Estate of Diane Arbus

DIANE ARBUS Veteran with a flag, N.Y.C. 1971 © The Estate of Diane Arbus

Veteran with a flag, N.Y.C. 1971 doesn’t appear extraordinary at first. He wears a nice blazer, a clean shirt with a starched collar, and his Veterans of Foreign Wars hat, and he holds an American flag. He could be taking part in a Veteran’s Day parade celebration. But he’s relaxed his grip on his flag, which seems like it might slide through his fist at any moment. He is distracted — by what? It could be something happening in the street, or it could be what he has seen, as a veteran of any of America’s grisly 20th century wars. The look in his eyes doesn’t exactly scream, “‘Murricuh!”. It just screams. Possibly something more like, Oh woe is me, to have seen what I have seen, see what I see. It is hard to resist making deductions from the pairing of that cheap, crumpled flag with the abject expression on the soldier’s face, and that is also what makes the image hard to look at. Some of Arbus’s subjects were marginalized by nature; others by their society or their place in history. She takes what we don’t like to look at and shows it to us anyway, offering no cheap promises to reveal some hidden beauty in it. One gets the sense that Arbus expected her viewers to be made of sterner stuff than those who would require a side of uplift to make their hard truths more palatable.

All of this aligns with the received interpretations of her work, or at least doesn’t deviate too dramatically from them. And so one could view the images in “Diane Arbus 1971-1956″ as emblematic of her oeuvre and fame. But then there are those categories again, which at first seem so arbitrary, not least because many of the images could be made a case for as being equally suited to the categories that they don’t appear in. But a strange thing happens when one does regard them with Fraenkel’s delineations in mind. As in Two friends at home, the focus of the photographs is no longer the subjects themselves, or the “freakish” things about them that inspired Arbus to seek them out, but rather something more complicated, possibly unphotographable. Five children in a common room appears under “Interiors: the meanings of rooms.” Well, obviously, you could say; the common room is where the children converge and play and fight and make noise. But is there a greater significance to this particular room that could justify Fraenkel choosing this apparently redundant heading? Think of the childrens’ rooms you’ve seen and been in, whether they were in homes, classrooms, daycare or community centers. Now try to remember a single one that did not have some sort of decorations on the walls for the kids to look at, or age- and size-appropriate toys to play with. People who care for “normal” children make an effort to create a space for them that is both sensorially stimulating and joyful. For the children in Arbus’s “common room,” however, it was considered sufficient to herd them into a low-ceilinged cell with blank walls, dingy floor tiles, and a trike none of them can actually ride. The significance of this room is the revelation of our unconscionable negligence towards the people we’ve decided just aren’t worth the bother. The most brutal Arbussian truth in this image isn’t about the children; it’s about us.

And the Veteran — he appears under “People being somebody.” Well, yes, he is a veteran. But “He is somebody” is different from “He is being somebody.” “Being” somebody is assuming a role, like an actor; it connotes effort and deliberation, a distance between the private and presented selves. There is a chasm between the jaunty hat and flag and the thousand-yard stare, just as there is a chasm between wars and the parades that commemorate them. In his youth this man might have been sent to do the very worst things it is possible for one human being to do to another. The same country that asked, or ordered, him to do that, now gives this grown man some cheap felt and a toy flag to wave and expects him play this bloodless, PG version of the conquering hero, pretending that the one has anything to do with the other, even, astonishingly, that the latter is a sort of reward for the former. The image is especially damning now, considering that our present veterans are struggling to win the kinds of compensation previous generations were guaranteed, like healthcare and education. The veteran isn’t unusual for trying to be the man his country expects of him. But what sort of country expects him to be this man?

DIANE ARBUS Kid in black-face with friend, N.Y.C. 1957 © The Estate of Diane Arbus

DIANE ARBUS
Kid in black-face with friend, N.Y.C. 1957
© The Estate of Diane Arbus

It is hard to view Arbus’s work uninfluenced by the pervasive mythology around it. Anyone who’s never seen an Arbus photograph in person may nevertheless be familiar with her as the photographer of “freaks” (a designation she bristled at). What Fraenkel’s thematic groupings have done is to shift the focus of each image to the unexpected, and so encourage the viewer to glean from it something different from what the mythology would indicate. Again and again, when traveling through the galleries and examining each photograph, the headings they are grouped under cause one to do a mental double-take. A dominatrix and her client are not just a sad, paunchy little man in socks and his hired fetish. They’re two people, like any other two, in a heartbreakingly tender embrace that transcends commerce and conceals the ‘mystery that brought them together.’ A girl and boy in Washington Square Park stare out through very stoned eyes. Fraenkel asks us to do more than gawk at the hippies as another of Arbus’s coldblooded anthropological studies, and invokes “Recognition.” This brings our focus out of the image and into the space between it and us. What is it the kids are recognizing? What might we recognize in them? The headings redirect our focus to something left out of the visual plane, that the imagination must conjure and have a good wrastle with, something unphotographable. Whether Arbus herself had any such ideas about her work is immaterial; the risk one takes in making art is that someone else will re-envision it in a way that is as provocative as it is irrelevant, as enriching as it is dubious. Jeffrey Fraenkel’s exercise is an example of how good curation can clear away the fumes of legend and present work we think we know, afresh.

Well-played, sir, well-played.

This article first appeared on the Huffington Post.

This entry was posted in ART, damn good, photography, REVIEWS, San Francisco and tagged , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

27 Responses to Curation as a New Translation: Diane Arbus at Fraenkel Gallery, Huffington Post

  1. I have seen that nowadays, more and more people are attracted to cams and the area
    of images. However, being photographer, it’s important to first devote so much
    of your time deciding which model of video camera to buy and
    moving via store to store just so you could possibly buy the cheapest camera of
    the brand you have decided to choose. But it would not end generally there.

    You also have to consider whether you should buy a digital digital camera extended warranty.
    Thanks a bunch for the good recommendations I gained from your web site.

    http://www.stepuplink.com/story.php?title=citation-needed-the-actual-nike-dunk-sb-tiffany-design-has-been-in-addition-adapted-,http://gsuhdakn11.simplesite.com/288883179/1498007/posting/the-complete-vintage-wonders-amongst-links-of-london-friendship-bracelet-sale-style-item

  2. Very shortly this web site will be famous amid all blogging
    and site-building viewers, due to it’s pleasant articles or
    reviews

  3. My brother recommended I may like this website.
    He was once entirely right. This put up truly
    made my day. You cann’t believe just how much time I had spent for this information!
    Thanks!

  4. It would be a lot easier and affordable for them to have container boxes as
    it is the most convenient way to at least have a mini
    garden in a limited residential area. Placing planter boxes on your deck rails is a great way to green up
    your deck without the worry of knocking flower
    pots off the rail. * If you have tomatoes that are not ripe enough, put them
    in a brown paper bag.

  5. Pretty nice post. I just stumbled upon your blog and wanted
    to say that I’ve really enjoyed surfing around your
    blog posts. In any case I will be subscribing to your feed
    and I hope you write again very soon!

  6. start blog says:

    It provides you all the features you need to start out, with a blog and provide your business the required visibility needed
    for marketing and providing you a platform to put your
    business out there. You can’t write about the stuff your audience wants to know about if you don’t know who they are.
    When you have chosen a blogging platform, the next step is to choose a name.

  7. What’s up friends, its great article regarding teachingand entirely
    explained, keep it up all the time.

  8. Hey there would you mind letting me know which web host you’re using?
    I’ve loaded your blog in 3 different web browsers and I
    must say this blog loads a lot faster then most.
    Can you recommend a good web hosting provider at a honest price?
    Thanks a lot, I appreciate it!

  9. I don’t even know how I ended up here, but I thought this post was good.

    I do not know who you are but definitely you are going to a
    famous blogger if you are not already ;) Cheers!

  10. If you wish your business to cultivate, it’s important to pay attention for your
    USP. Go on the Content Tab on top of the new window that came up.

    You get to use the best features for instance innovative site
    building tools, customized email accounts, blog and podcast tools,
    photo albums as well as a host of such kinds of services,
    completely aimed towards getting your online business over the internet from
    the best possible way.

  11. In commenting on those pro athletes who
    attempt to transition to pro golf,. Many true antiques might be
    found online at places like e – Bay or any other auction sites and also may be found through
    traditional thrift shops and antique stores. Successful multi-level marketing companies have
    huge advertising budgets, however, that they spend it differs greatly from traditional
    business.

  12. I believe this is one of the so much important info for me.

    And i am glad studying your article. But should observation on few general issues, The web site taste is perfect, the articles is really excellent : D.
    Just right job, cheers

  13. Madonna says:

    Having adequate water happens to be crucial to prevent lack of fluids.

    Of course, the things listed in this information don’t take into account all age reversing products available.
    The only issue with this is that IGF-1 is
    on Major League Baseball’s set of banned substances,
    therefore if theigf-1 spray actually mayenhance IGF-1,
    people could possibly be busted for making use of theitem.

  14. Hi there! This post couldn’t be written much better!
    Going through this article reminds me of my previous roommate!
    He always kept preaching about this. I most certainly will
    forward this article to him. Fairly certain he will have a good read.
    Thanks for sharing!

  15. Marla says:

    For example, and information. Week #10 and the contractor to assist with the best deals, owned by the end of year.
    No work is insured. Your home improvement projects can take you longer.
    You may need to be beneficial for the primary contractor exceeds $10, 000 in professional fees.

  16. Vance says:

    Hello my friend! I want to say that this article is amazing, great written and
    come with almost all significant infos. I would like to
    see more posts like this .

  17. Situs Judi says:

    Oh my goodness! Impressive article dude! Thank
    you, However I am having issues with your RSS. I don’t understand the reason why I cannot join it.
    Is there anyone else having identical RSS problems?
    Anyone who knows the answer will you kindly respond?
    Thanks!!

  18. Pretty section of content. I just stumbled upon your site and in accession capital to assert that I
    acquire actually enjoyed account your blog posts. Anyway I’ll be subscribing to your feeds and even I achievement you access consistently rapidly.

  19. Awesome! Its actually remarkable paragraph, I have got much clear idea about from this article.

  20. Robby says:

    Hi, I wish for to subscribe for this website to obtain hottest updates, therefore where can i do it
    please help out.

  21. vegas escort says:

    It’s an amazing piece of writing in favor of all the online visitors; they will take advantage from it I am sure.

  22. Gabriele says:

    Do you mind if I quote a few of your articles as long as I provide
    credit and sources back to your blog? My blog is in the
    very same niche as yours and my visitors would really benefit from some of the information you provide here.
    Please let me know if this ok with you. Regards!

  23. Dacă credeți că ați simply’re excitat de ideea simpla de swinging , trebuie doar
    să așteptați până când sari în . Bărbații sunt mai interesați
    în picioare mai groase decat de picioarele musculoase pentru a beneficia de distincții sexuale .

  24. Web design is the content in terms of disk space, is rooted
    in our case only and search engine marketing avoid leaving them written down anywhere that your
    design into consideration. 2 You can usually choose between all of the actual site.
    Step 8Wow and if you are building. 4 Design your website will always be less visible than, it is acceptable
    much of the latest technologies and use another resource instead.

    During web design in San Diego web design search engine marketing that clearly
    reflects in their design, custom website development
    process.

  25. seo campaign says:

    In a very diverse clientage ranging from basic, static web pages.
    Game designers must have quality content that is highly
    significant, try to lead generation answer than open-ended questions.
    Make action steps clear and visible. Eventually, they are so many online universities
    and wed design firms resolution knows you they can be made up.
    The public is going to focus on the Web will never return again. The way of generating revenue.
    This is the time, then we may find yourself ending up with reflected that need.

  26. Gregory says:

    Doing contractor this leaves additional storage space that
    would be much more likely to face and you have the
    money. Would you like the adult voice in a fashion that has contractor to happen consistently or
    you can start right away. The letter points to consider your budget.
    In essence you are being squeezed across the nation today.
    They provide expert and experienced experts who offer reliable services in the agreement properly
    and the consequences of this opportunity.

  27. buy btv solo says:

    Valuable info. Lucky me I discovered your web site accidentally,
    and I’m shocked why this coincidence did not happened earlier!
    I bookmarked it.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s